Roaster's Choice Coffee Subscription
Put coffee exploration on auto-pilot with our Roaster's Choice subscription. Every year, we release over 20 distinct single-origin coffees sourced directly from exceptional producers worldwide. Our roasters select from our current limited-release lineup and ship them straight to your door on your schedule. Save 10% on every shipment, and orders over $30 ship free.
Unlike our year-round blends, single-origin coffees showcase a specific place—sometimes a single farm, sometimes a particular region. For most of these coffees, we maintain direct relationships with the farmers who grow them. Because coffee harvests are seasonal and vary by region, our selection shifts throughout the year. What arrives in October might taste nothing like what you received in March—and that's exactly the point.
Perfect for anyone who wants to expand their coffee knowledge without doing the research, or for established enthusiasts who trust us to bring them something exceptional and unexpected.
Subscribe & Save
Our subscriptions are highly customizable, easy to manage, and can be cancelled at any time.
Select "Subscribe & Save" and then choose the frequency that you want to get fresh roasted coffee and syrups to your door.
Orders are auto-generated and shipped to you fresh-roasted by our coffee team.
Swap products, skip orders, or cancel any time, all through conversational text messages (select "Allow me to modify my subscription via Text" at checkout).
Frothy Monkey Subscription SMS Management
Each completed subscription order gives you money back that you can spend on future subscription orders.
Orders 1-9*: Earn 2% back
Orders 10+: Earn 4% back
CUPS PER BAG SIZE
Freshness Tip: Choose the size that you'll drink within 3 to 4 weeks
12 ounces
~18 cups
5 pounds
~121 cups
Moved here 5 years ago and have always loved fresh roasted coffee. I do the expresso thing and grind my beans then use a Gaggia Classic Pro to extract the espresso shots. For me ONLY Frothy Monkey has the best roasted beans AND variety in the greater Nashville area.
I do the monthly Roasters Choice delivery to home as its like Christmas when I get the delivery. I am FM fanboi, but hey , THEY ARE THE BEST!
Kind Regards ~ JC
Hey Jonathan, that's a thoughtful setup, Gaggia and fresh-ground beans. Thank you for trusting us with the daily pull.
Long time Frothy Monkey Coffee enjoyer. Moved here from Maryland 5 years ago and found FM coffee and never looked back. Love that the coffee is fresh roasted and delivered within 2 days of roasting.
FM coffees subscriber choice is AMAZING for flavor variety and depth of notes. Seriously its the BEST. I grind and pull coffee shots every morning with FM.
Huge fan!
Jonathan C. - Goodlettsville, TN
Hey Jonathan, from a fellow East Coast to Nashville transplant it's awesome to here this. Thanks for being part of the crew for five years!
This subscription used to be wonderful. Now nobody is paying attention to the output, so you end up with the same flavor nearly every time. It was a household joke until Rwanda showed up for the 5th time. Then I cancelled my subscription.
I’ve already sent this message twice, but since the AI keeps asking, I’m going to keep sending you the message. Maybe some human beings will read this and care.
Hey Christopher, this one's on us. Roaster's Choice is absolutely supposed to be about variety, and shipping the same coffee five times in a row is the complete opposite. We weren't paying close enough attention to your subscription. I'll look into what happened on your account and reach out to you today.
The Indabayo coffee was decent, but on a 2 week reoccurring subscription I received it 3 times.i was hoping for more variation. And the last shipment had no roast date. There are coffees I'd like to try from frothy monkey in the future, but it won't be via roasters choice.
Hey David, this is the kind of feedback we need to see. Getting the same coffee three times on a Roaster's Choice isn't how that's supposed to work, and the missing roast date is on us. Sorry for the mix-up. We'll get with our roasting team on both. If you want to stick around and pick your own coffees going forward, we'd love to have you back. Thanks!
Love my subscription, the customer service has been immaculate, even a few times when there were small issues. I appreciate the teams' willingness to work with me and my requests when I asked to narrow down my origins of choice on my account or when I was unhappy with one batch.
Hey Adriana, thank you so much for this! We're stoked to have you as a subscriber, and it means a lot to hear that the experience has been a good one, even when things weren't perfect. That's honestly the part we care about most. We love being able to dial in your subscription to match what you're into, and we're always happy to help if your preferences shift. Thanks for sticking with us!
I've had the roaster's choice subscription for over a year and I absolutely love it. There have been a few repeated roasts, but for the most part, each month I receive a new, interesting flavor. The repeats are always ones I've enjoyed a lot previously, so no complaints there either. I think this is 100% worth the price to have fun, high quality coffee delivered to your door.
So glad Roaster's Choice has been a hit overall. We'll keep working to bring you new-to-you coffees each month. Thank you for subscribing!
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Your coffee ships fresh. We roast throughout the week and pack orders as they come in to ensure you're getting beans at their peak.
- Orders placed Monday–Thursday before 2pm CST ship the next business day.
- Orders placed Monday–Thursday after 2pm CST ship within two business days.
- Orders placed Friday–Sunday are packed on Monday and ship within 1-2 business days.
During holidays and promotional periods, please allow 2-3 additional business days for processing and shipping.
-
We offer four grind options to match how you're brewing:
- Drip / Pour-Over — Works for automatic drip machines, pour-over brewers (V60, Kalita, Chemex), and AeroPress. This is the most versatile grind and covers most home brewing methods.
- Fine (Espresso) — Ground specifically for espresso machines. It's very fine, which means it'll over-extract and taste bitter or chalky if you use it in drip or pour-over methods. Only use this if you're pulling shots.
- French Press — Coarser grind for traditional French Press brewing, cold brew, or large-batch Chemex (60+ grams of coffee). The larger grind size prevents over-extraction during longer steep times.
- Cold Brew — Coarse grind optimized for cold brew methods with extended steeping (12-24 hours). Similar to French Press but dialed in for cold water extraction.
Not sure? Drip / Pour-Over is your safest bet if you're brewing with anything other than an espresso machine or doing cold brew.
- Drip / Pour-Over — Works for automatic drip machines, pour-over brewers (V60, Kalita, Chemex), and AeroPress. This is the most versatile grind and covers most home brewing methods.
-
Coffee brewing sits somewhere between science and personal preference. There's no single "right" way, just the way that works for you.
We've put together brew guides for:- Chemex
- Kalita Wave 185
- French Press
- Auto-Drip Brewer
- Cold Brew
- Single-Serve
Visit our brewing page here.
Each guide covers ratios, grind size, and timing. These technical foundations help you dial in your perfect coffee. From there, it's yours to adjust. A little more coffee for boldness, a slightly coarser grind for clarity, water temperature shifts for sweetness or brightness. The variables matter, but so does what you actually enjoy drinking.
Start with a guide that matches your equipment, brew a few rounds, and notice what changes when you tweak one thing at a time. That's how you find your version.
-
We offer signature and single-origin coffees that range from light to dark roast, each crafted to highlight different flavor profiles and brewing methods.
- 12South — Our most versatile medium roast. Works beautifully as drip, cold brew, or espresso.
- Brunch — A vibrant light roast breakfast blend. Perfect for pour-over or drip.
- Brute — Bold, creamy, and comforting. A darker roast best brewed in a French press.
- Howler — Our espresso blend. Medium roast that shines in milk drinks but stands strong on its own.
- Eventide Decaf — Full-bodied, dark-roasted decaf. Decaffeinated with the sugarcane method. Perfect for evenings.
- Midshift Half Caff — Half the caffeine, full flavor. Balanced medium roast that works any time of day.
- Frothy Cold Brew — Developed for cold extraction but versatile across methods. Naturally sweet.
- Single-Origin Coffees - Our rotating selection showcases beans from specific farms and regions. Selections change seasonally based on harvest and availability.
- 12South — Our most versatile medium roast. Works beautifully as drip, cold brew, or espresso.